Teams Sheldon Cotterell played for

TestWest Indies (2013/14-2014/15)
ODIWest Indies (2014/15-2021)
International Twenty20West Indies (2013/14-2021/22)
Main FCJamaica (2010/11-2015/16)
 Sagicor High Performance Centre (2014)
 Trinidad and Tobago (2016/17-2017/18)
 Leeward Islands (2018/19)
Main ListAJamaica (2012/13-2020/21)
 Sagicor High Performance Centre (2014)
 Trinidad and Tobago (2016/17-2017/18)
 Leeward Islands (2018/19)
Main Twenty20Jamaica (2010/11-2012/13)
 Antigua Hawksbills (2013-2014)
 Sagicor High Performance Centre (2014)
 St Kitts and Nevis Patriots (2015-2021)
 Kings XI Punjab (2020/21)
Other FCWest Indies A (2013-2017/18)
 West Indians (2013/14)
 West Indies (2013/14-2014/15)
Other ListAWest Indies A (2013-2017/18)
 West Indies (2014/15-2021)
Other Twenty20West Indies (2013/14-2021/22)
 West Indies Board President's XI (2017)
World CupWest Indies (2019)
World Cup Super LeagueWest Indies (2021)
Indian Premier LeagueKings XI Punjab (2020/21)
Caribbean Premier LeagueAntigua Hawksbills (2013-2014)
 St Kitts and Nevis Patriots (2015-2021)
West Indies CompetitionJamaica (2010/11-2015/16)
 Trinidad and Tobago (2016/17-2017/18)
 Leeward Islands (2018/19)
MiscellaneousSagicor High Performance Centre (2012/13)
 KA Edwards' XI (2013/14)
 P Palmer's XI (2013/14)
 West Indies (2013/14-2019)
 West Indians (2014/15-2019/20)
 Vancouver Knights (2018)
 Deccan Gladiators (2019/20)
 Team Abu Dhabi (2021/22)